Book summary: Living at the Bottom of the Ocean by David Schnarch

    Picture the coral reef in Finding Nemo: sunlight through the water, bright fish everywhere. Now picture the bottom of the ocean. No light, no color, fish with huge teeth and lanterns growing out of their foreheads. The only rule is kill or be killed.

    When you get into an argument with your partner, your brain goes to the bottom of the ocean. You lose your capacity for courage, kindness, and reason, and you can think of only one thing: I have to win. Schnarch called this a regression. Your best bet is to swim for the surface. It helps me to say to myself, "I'm regressed." I also move my arms like I'm swimming. It sounds ridiculous, but it's less ridiculous than how I act when I'm regressed.

    Click here to download a free PDF copy of the entire book.

    On this page
    1. Chapter 1: You’re Not Having Feelings, You’re Drowning in Them!
    2. Chapter 2: Sinking into the Abyss
    3. Chapter 3: Living Submerged
    4. Chapter 4: What Drags You Down?
    5. Chapter 5: The Mariana Trench Model of Regressions
    6. Chapter 6: Coming Up from The Depths
    7. Chapter 7: You Won’t Find Nemo Down Here!
    8. Chapter 8: Heading Towards the Surface
    9. Chapter 9: Revisualizations Make You Buoyant
    10. Chapter 10: Written Mental Dialogues Increase Your Ascent
    11. Chapter 11: Facing Your Antagonist Puts the Surface Within Reach
    12. Chapter 12: Reaching Warmth and Sunlight!
    13. More book summaries: Growing up and the family you came from

    Chapter 1: You’re Not Having Feelings, You’re Drowning in Them!

    The book opens with Elizabeth. One morning she starts thinking about what people will say about her divorce, and suddenly she is drowning in worthlessness. Her husband, Dennis, thinks she is crazy, and earlier therapists diagnosed her with borderline personality disorder. Schnarch says he has helped many people who had severe emotional crashes all their lives get them under control.

    Some people cave in like this. Others blow up with tirades and screaming. Schnarch calls both regressions: periods of reduced cognitive and emotional functioning, caused by shifts in how the brain is working. They can last a moment or a lifetime.

    Using Paul MacLean’s triune brain model, he describes regression as control shifting from the prefrontal cortex to the older mammalian and reptilian parts of the brain. One rule runs through the whole book. You’re responsible for what you do even when you’re deeply regressed.

    Chapter 2: Sinking into the Abyss

    Elizabeth is sitting in a park on a sunny afternoon when Dennis calls. His lawyer is sending a new, less generous divorce proposal, even though Dennis had told her she didn’t need a lawyer. Elizabeth goes tongue-tied, nauseated, cold and clammy. Schnarch calls this the quicksand reaction, when the bottom falls out.

    He describes typical behavior in acute regressions. People climb on top of someone else to keep themselves afloat, the way Elizabeth’s mother shrieked at her, age nine, after a visit to the principal’s office. They grab the moral high ground, pound on someone, act wounded, or generate anger on the spot.

    Regressions usually happen when high anxiety meets high meaning, as with marital problems, parents and in-laws, or money. Schnarch argues that temper problems, panic attacks, crushing low self-worth, and borderline episodes often turn out to be acute regressions. Approached that way, he says, they are treatable.

    Chapter 3: Living Submerged

    Stephan is a well-established plastic surgeon. His wife, Anne Marie, is a former model. Their marriage is in tatters, and each blames the other’s parents. One of their stock lines is “If you’re not going to deal with your parents, I don’t have to deal with mine!” Each can see the other’s blind spots but not their own.

    This chapter introduces the second type of regression, the long-term steady-state regression. It comes on gradually, can last for years or decades, and feels normal, so you come to think it’s your personality. You can only recognize it looking back, once your functioning comes up. Schnarch is not sure it differs from depression, and he thinks it is often mistaken for ADHD or autism.

    Its effects include living “asleep,” holes in your autobiographical memory, gaps in your mind-mapping radar, and emotional dead spots. Stephan has what Schnarch calls antisocial empathy. He can read what others feel, but he doesn’t care. Schnarch’s aim is to resolve the regression until he becomes capable of caring. Waking up, Schnarch warns, is neither easy nor pleasant.

    Chapter 4: What Drags You Down?

    Elizabeth depends on what Schnarch calls a reflected sense of self, feeling fine only when others approve. In one session she reports punching Dennis in the chest during a fight. She is horrified. Schnarch smiles, because her shock at herself is a good sign. Looking at that moment brings up memories of being hit by both parents.

    Schnarch names five major causes of regression:

    1. Anxiety and meaning
    2. Traumatic mind mapping
    3. Interpersonal moves
    4. Weak 4 Points of Balance
    5. Reactive regressions

    Mind mapping is reading what is in other people’s heads. Traumatic mind mapping happens when what you see there is so awful it traumatizes your brain. Its hallmark is spaghetti brain, a sharp drop in thinking. Severe cases set off a disgust reaction centered in the anterior insula, which shuts down mind mapping. A move is an attempt to manipulate you. The Four Points of Balance are Solid Flexible Self, Quiet Mind and Calm Heart, Grounded Responding, and Meaningful Endurance. When they are weak, regressions come easier.

    Reactive regressions are triggered by getting better. Seeing the truth clearly can make your brain fall apart for a while. Schnarch also lists trait anxiety, anticipatory traumatic mind mapping, and a variant of the MAOA gene that produces low amounts of the enzyme as things that make some people more prone to regress.

    Chapter 5: The Mariana Trench Model of Regressions

    Elizabeth snaps a spatula against the stove and yells that she is “sick and tired of being treated worse than a slave!” as Dennis and their son, Paul, stare.

    Schnarch asks readers to picture the Mariana Trench, nearly seven miles deep at the Challenger Deep, cold, dark, and crushing. The more regressed you are, the deeper you have sunk. A severe acute regression puts you at the bottom with the Ugly Fish, the strange predators of the deep sea. When an acute regression passes, you may only come up to about a mile down. That is a steady-state regression, though it feels like the surface.

    The model lets you track your depth, and its unflattering picture of yourself helps you stop playing the victim. The instruction for deep regressions is simple: “Swim for the surface!”

    In one session Schnarch asks Elizabeth whether she is a heart-eater, someone who enjoys inducing guilt and grief when she regresses. She says yes. He calls this a turning point. She stayed regulated, confronted herself, and showed self-awareness in the middle of a regression.

    Chapter 6: Coming Up from The Depths

    Coming up is doable but not easy. Schnarch lists predictable pitfalls, such as assuming you are untreatable or blaming the terrible people around you. Divers put the plan in a phrase: “Plan your dive and dive your plan.”

    He introduces Crucible Neurobiological Therapy (CNT), which is built on mind mapping and uses right-brain methods like visualizations and written mental dialogues. Here he parts ways with Murray Bowen. Bowen’s therapy is calm and low-anxiety. Crucible work happens near the upper end of your window of tolerance, because moderate to high anxiety and meaning make the brain more plastic.

    He describes four kinds of alliance: collaborative, collusive, combative, and no alliance. The golden rule of a collaborative alliance is that the first person you confront is you. For Stephan and Anne Marie, the test is his father’s 75th birthday party. Stephan’s mother insists on the seating plan. The couple tells his parents they won’t attend unless they can sit where they’re both comfortable. Schnarch calls this a moment of meeting, a charged moment that changes the relationship and, he says, rewires the brain. Afterward the couple shows brightening, his term for the visible lift in face, eyes, and voice as someone comes out of regression.

    Chapter 7: You Won’t Find Nemo Down Here!

    In a severe regression you aren’t swimming with cute clownfish. Self-awareness disappears and you feel completely right. So the first step is to recognize it and say the two magic words, “I’m regressed!” Saying you are upset or angry doesn’t work, because it keeps you focused on feelings instead of brain state.

    Next, exercise your will in the middle of the regression. Then relax on purpose. Schnarch compares overwhelming feelings to a riptide. You don’t fight the undertow. You relax and float. His best practices include assuming you’re regressed until proven otherwise and learning the “mouth” of your regressions, the thoughts and feelings that mark the way in.

    At first you notice regressions only afterward. With practice you catch them in the middle. Elizabeth gets there one evening when she stops a harangue at Paul mid-sentence and tells him she heard herself and was regressed. Later Paul comes to breakfast warning, “Don’t talk to me! I’m regressed!”

    When your partner is the Ugly Fish, keep one eye on yourself, because you are probably regressing too. Don’t apologize for things you didn’t do. Don’t try to reason with them, act intimidated, or tell them they’re regressed. Schnarch says you can still keep a collaborative alliance alone, because its responsibilities are unilateral.

    Chapter 8: Heading Towards the Surface

    We want waking up to be like Sleeping Beauty, rescued by someone else’s kiss. Schnarch says it usually takes a kick instead, and you have to deliver it yourself. Stephan’s stand on the birthday seating was progress, but he still avoids his parents.

    Schnarch describes a reliable four-stage pattern of awakening:

    1. First you’re asleep and think you’re awake.
    2. You start to wake up and think you’re in a nightmare.
    3. You want to go back to sleep and tell yourself that you’re awake.
    4. If you stay awake and don’t go back to sleep, the nightmare passes and you just remain awake.

    As you wake up, the nightmare gets worse before it lifts. You see what others have done and how you took part. Schnarch also describes emotional super glue, the trauma bonding that comes from repeated disgust reactions. One early sign of progress: Stephan feels himself regressing as he passes a homeless man at a train station, catches it, gives him a few dollars, and feels his functioning come back. As a steady-state regression lifts, Schnarch says, people think more clearly, feel better, and have more energy and sexual desire.

    Chapter 9: Revisualizations Make You Buoyant

    Revisualization means reviewing past experiences through visual imagery rather than verbal recall. Schnarch calls it gazing into the crystal ball of your mind.

    The science centers on two memory systems. Situationally accessible memory (SAM) is implicit and image-based. Verbally accessible memory (VAM) is your spoken life story. Traumatic mind mapping leaves the two out of sync, and revisualizing helps bring them together. In one session Elizabeth revisualizes walking past a store window with her father at fifteen. He stares at a bikini-clad mannequin and keeps telling her she would look good in that suit. When Schnarch asks what was in her father’s mind, she finally says it out loud. He was thinking about her sexually.

    The game plan has three steps: set the stage, watch the movie, and map your antagonist’s mind. Schnarch wants people to work near the upper end of their window of tolerance, not past it. If you become unable to function, can’t sleep for days, or think about harming yourself or someone else, he says to stop and get professional help.

    Chapter 10: Written Mental Dialogues Increase Your Ascent

    A written mental dialogue looks like a play script. You write your lines and your antagonist’s lines, based on your map of that person’s mind. Write it in one pass without editing, with one antagonist at a time. Schnarch notes that some clients will pay to talk for hours in therapy but get squirrely when it’s time to write.

    The method has three steps:

    1. Write your initial dialogues.
    2. Analyze your dialogues.
    3. Improve your responses.

    Analysis means finding the moves and what they say about what the antagonist wants. Improving means showing the antagonist you can see what they are doing, staying on message, and not bluffing or threatening. Schnarch warns that antagonists often switch to a Plan B once you handle their usual tactics.

    Elizabeth’s first dialogue with her father ends with him using her mother’s denial against her. Stephan’s dialogue with his father about a loan shows him finally taking a position: “I’m not trying to insult you; I’m just describing you.”

    Chapter 11: Facing Your Antagonist Puts the Surface Within Reach

    Now the work moves to face-to-face encounters. Schnarch says there is often no substitute for dealing with a living antagonist directly. The point is not to set other people straight. It is to take a new place in the world. He calls the balance of self-restraint and self-empowerment the hallmark of differentiation.

    People important to you will make moves on you, and those who make hard-to-handle moves know what they are doing. Schnarch lays out six steps for handling them:

    1. Watch the move.
    2. Analyze the move.
    3. Break the move into its parts.
    4. Figure out what your antagonist wants.
    5. Map your antagonist’s mind.
    6. Respond to the move.

    Elizabeth’s mother announces she will leave sixty-five percent of her estate to Elizabeth’s brother, then asks what Elizabeth thinks. Elizabeth has total spaghetti brain. In their next conversation she tells her mother the money is hers to divide, but she won’t pretend the plan was meant to be fair. She also points out that her mother knew how she would feel and asked her to sign off anyway.

    Elizabeth’s father has died, so she settles things with him in written dialogues. In the last one she refuses to take his bait and tells him they’re done. Schnarch writes that Elizabeth “didn’t need to get even. She just needed to get free.” She also faces Dennis’s long history of affairs and her own blindness to them.

    Chapter 12: Reaching Warmth and Sunlight!

    The last chapter follows the water up through the thermocline into the sunlight zone. Warm water can feel strange if your comfort zone is seven miles down.

    Stephan’s father asks him to put money into another high-risk deal. Using the six steps, Stephan sees that his parents want his money and also his mind, meaning his willingness to stay blind to who they are. He says no and tells them it is a relationship issue. His father goes quiet. His mother attacks with a barrage of questions meant to put him on the defensive. Anne Marie reaches out to her father about his drinking and to her brother, Jake, and gets little back. The section heading sums it up: you can’t rescue everyone. As the couple stops fighting about their parents, their marriage improves.

    He also covers aging Ugly Fish, where you still have the right to protect your children from abusive parents, and post-traumatic growth. He cites a review of thirty-nine studies in which thirty to seventy percent of trauma survivors reported positive changes. Stephan, Anne Marie, and Elizabeth all show it.

    The book ends in the shallows, where real love becomes possible. Life on the surface still has storms, but Schnarch closes with his one guarantee: life on the surface is a breeze compared to swimming with the Ugly Fish in the Mariana Trench.