What is Differentiation?

    Differentiation is your ability to be true to who you are while staying close to someone who matters to you.

    I don't use the word much in therapy because it's kind of nerdy. What I ask instead is: what would it take for you to feel okay when your partner disagrees with you? When they disapprove of you? When they don't treat you well?

    Those are the moments when it's hardest to treat your partner well. A less differentiated person handles disapproval, disagreement, and poor treatment badly. A more differentiated person handles them better. That's most of what the word means.

    Another way to picture it

    Falling in love is like two magnets pointed the right way: they pull toward each other without any effort. After a few years of marriage it can feel like the magnets have flipped and are pushing apart. Differentiation is flipping your own magnet back around, and when you do, it gets easier for your partner's magnet to flip too.

    • It's like being able to hold onto myself and belong to my wife.
    • It's my ability to be true to who I am while also being true to her.
    • It's my capacity to be close to her without losing my sense of self or my personal integrity.

    What it looks like in my marriage

    When my wife and I got married, we had a hard time with each other's disapproval. We both worked hard to get the other one to see things our way, or to approve of us, or at least not to judge us. As the years went on it became clear that we were different people who saw things differently and wanted different things. That felt really bad.

    What changed is that I learned to make room for the differences. When she disapproves of me now, it's still uncomfortable. But I've gotten used to the feeling, and I've learned that my job is to tolerate the discomfort, not to change her mind. It took me years.

    That freed up a lot of attention. Instead of chasing her approval, I can ask what kind of husband, father, and man I want to be, and work on earning my own respect. And instead of focusing on how she affects me, I can focus on how I affect her. What is it like for her to live with me? What is it like to be married to me?

    Why "happy wife, happy life" doesn't work

    In every marriage there's pressure going back and forth. I want my wife to act certain ways, and she wants me to act certain ways.

    If I'm actually going to change, it has to come from my desire to be a different person, not from her desire for me to be a different person. If I take the shortcut and just do what she wants, it goes against human nature. I haven't done the work of figuring out who I want to be.

    So the order matters. First I build a stronger sense of self. I look in the mirror and ask what kind of person I want to be. I might take her feedback into account, but it isn't the deciding factor. And as I care more about her, I may decide that I want to be the person she's asking for. I just can't skip the first step.

    Where the idea comes from

    Psychiatrist Murray Bowen called it differentiation of self. He saw it on a spectrum. People at the low end get swept up in the anxiety of the people around them. People at the high end can stay clear-headed when things get intense, and can be close to others without losing themselves. Bowen believed you mostly learn your level in the family you grew up in, and that you can keep growing it for the rest of your life.

    David Schnarch brought the idea into marriage and sex. In Passionate Marriage he argued that most couples rely on each other for validation, and that this keeps them stuck. When your sense of self depends on your partner's approval, you organize your life around managing their moods. Schnarch's alternative is to validate yourself, so you can hear hard things, share something vulnerable, and disagree without caving in or blowing up.

    Schnarch's Four Points of Balance

    In Intimacy & Desire, Schnarch breaks differentiation into four abilities he called the Four Points of Balance:

    1. Solid Flexible Self: being clear about who you are and what you're about, especially when your partner pressures you to adapt and conform. A solid self can still take advice, be influenced, and change its mind without losing its shape.
    2. Quiet Mind–Calm Heart: being able to calm yourself down, soothe your own hurts, and regulate your own anxieties.
    3. Grounded Responding: staying calm and not overreacting when your partner gets anxious or upset, instead of creating distance or running away.
    4. Meaningful Endurance: stepping up to face the issues in you and your relationship, and tolerating discomfort for the sake of growth.

    Schnarch's point was that couples get gridlocked when both people want the other one to make them feel better. It only takes one of you to strengthen your Four Points of Balance to start moving things.

    How to become more solid

    You build solidness by tolerating discomfort without falling apart. Every time you stay present in a hard conversation instead of shutting down or blowing up, you get a little more solid. Every time you hear something hard about yourself and don't collapse into shame or defensiveness, you get a little more solid. Every time you hold onto what you know is true even when your partner disagrees, you get a little more solid.

    It's like building muscle. You don't get stronger by avoiding the weight. Most people try to feel okay by getting their partner to cooperate: if they'd just validate me more, if they'd stop criticizing me. That's trying to get strong by making the weight lighter. Real solidness comes from finding out you can handle things you thought you couldn't.

    Why I think it matters more than the popular ideas

    You'll hear a lot more about attachment theory or narcissism than about differentiation. I think differentiation is the more powerful idea, because I can grow it regardless of what my wife does. It gives me the power to make things better on my end. The more powerful I feel in my marriage, the easier it is for me to change and be a better husband.

    It's a lifelong project. It doesn't happen overnight, and you can always get more differentiated.